Dedicated to the acceptance, medical treatment, & legal protection of individuals in the process of correcting the misalignment of their anatomical sex, & supporting their transition into society.
Springfield, VA, USA. Society (the women and men around us) has always been more comfortable if its members fall within certain known, established patterns: this is how we dress, this is what we say, this is w...
Springfield, VA, USA. On the last day of the court's term in the year twenty-oh-eight, the Supreme Court of the United States held that the Second Amendment [to the Constitution of the United States] protects ...
Springfield, VA, USA. Early in fetal development, before even a glimmer of genitalia, the central nervous system acquires its basic structure.
It is here, deep within the most complex structure ...
Springfield, VA, USA. Jesus wrote us the other day. At least I think it was Jesus (he works for the Family Research Council, doesnt he?). [N1] He seems to have visited us quite frequently in the last few...
Springfield, VA, USA. As we all know, at least those of us who pretend to have a well rounded education, one who asks a question is a fool for five minutes, but one who does not ask a question remains a fool f...
Springfield, VA, USA. Every four years since 1788, the United States of America holds an election for its President 2008 is no different [N1].
At the moment this written, there are two major c...
Springfield, VA, USA. For any woman whose voice is a husky contralto, being sir'd can be upsetting, but it is especially disheartening for HBS women.
My natural voice is a contralto in the same way that jazz pianist/singer Diana Krall's voice is a contralto: husky smoke that sounds like twenty years on the road singing in bars, drinking Maker's Mark whiskey, and smoking cigarettes.
As far as I know she doesn't smoke [1] but I have five dollars that says she sometimes gets sir'd on the phone just like any other woman whose voice is not the expected soft soprano.
Just like the majority of HBS women, at one time or another during their lives, woman whose voice is a husky contralto have most likely been sir'd . While disconcerting to any woman, it can be particularly upsetting for HBS women, especially those HBS women who are early in transition and whose self-confidence can be best described as fragile.
What are they trying to tell me?
Do they think I'm a joke?
What did I do to make them think I am a man?
What did I do wrong?
Former Marines sir EVERYONE on reflex the woman who is my director, me, the Major who is male, and random people on the phone and then apologetically self-correct if the person to whom they speak is female. Other than those who serve in the Federation on Star Trek, no military organization intentionally sirs women. When it happens, it happens inadvertently and then is quickly changed to Ma'am.
Most times, however, being sir'd is a simple mistake resulting from the speaker triggering on a husky voice (after talking to soprano's most of day) while not looking up at person who has just spoken. Doesn't necessarily help the HBS woman who, in her inner heart of hearts, may want to just disappear to know that the mistake isn't hers.
We are all a little paranoid, always checking for the unconscious sir or hidden slight.
Why is that man staring at me?
Take a deep breath, men look at all women that way. They feel it is their right and imperative to look lustily at women and judge their sexual suitability (meaning does the woman turn the man on?). Using short words and sentences: men look at women. Get over it.
Why is that woman staring at me?
Take a deeper breath, all women look at all other women, checking out new fashions, make-up, hairstyles, evaluating whether the other woman has it together or not, wondering where they could buy a blouse like the one you are wearing. Relax. It's part of being a woman, part of the sisterhood of women in a world dominated by men. Women worry about other women: Are they upset? Do they look harried? She looks really hot, I wonder is she is a dyke like me?
Men look, women look, and when they do look, it probably has nothing to do with the woman at whom they are looking was born with HBS.
But even the most self confident HBS woman can be put off stride if she thinks she has been addressed as Sir.
Sir
a respectful or formal term of address used to a man. No women allowed, no sir.
Sir
the distinctive title of a knight or baronet. No women need apply.
Sir
a lord or gentleman noble sirs and ladies that's pretty clear.
Sir is an English honorific used in several modern contexts. It was once used (without the person's name) as a courtesy title among equals, but in common usage it is now usually reserved for one of superior rank or status, such as an educator or commanding officer, or in age (especially by a minor); as a form of address from a merchant to a customer; in formal correspondence (Dear Sir, Right Reverend Sir); or to a stranger (Sir, you've dropped your hat).
The equivalent for a woman is madam [2].
When a woman gets sir'd, she can
Assume it was a mistake and ignore it
Assume it was intentional and ignore it (why let a jerk get the upper hand?)
Stare in disbelief at the speaker and wait for him to correct himself (my favorite)
Gently correct the speaker using humor (you seem a bit distracted.)
Firmly correct the speaker (to whom are you speaking?)
Go postal, ask for the manager or supervisor, and suggest the speaker be terminated immediately (from his job or from the planet, woman's choice).
There is another alternative that a lot of HBS women, especially those early in transition, frequent: they remove themselves from the situation, go home, and over-process what just happened. The good sign is that over-processing is endemic to women a guy would just think the speaker was an ass-hole. The bad part of reacting this way is that what just happened probably did not happen because of anything the HBS woman did. Most times the speaker made an unintentional error not aimed at the HBS woman.
Three or four years post-op, HBS women seldom worry about sir-ing, at least no more than any other woman. HBS women who are still in transition would better serve themselves to cut their over-processing at least in half, and would best serve themselves by following the example of the experienced post-ops: don't spend hours dwelling on someone else's verbal slip.
The telephone, however, is another thing altogether.
Telephones were originally spec'd to best reproduce the male voice. The higher ranges of human speech (those that include the harmonics that are part of a female voice) are artificially depressed. Men were working in business, women were working at home. Nobody has ever redesigned the pitch range and harmonics to better reproduce male and female voices.
The bottom line is men's voices sound better on phones, women's voices sound deeper than they actually are, and contralto voices, including those of HBS women, are sir'd more often than one would expect, especially since a lot of my inbound phone calls sound like this:
Ring
Hello?
This is Bob Smith from Universal Surveys Incorporated. May I speak to Lisa Thompson?
Speaking.
I won't take much of your time, sir.
Ma'am. I'm a woman. Lisa is a woman's name.
I apologize. If I could just have a moment of your time, sir.
Where are you calling from, India or Pakistan?
I don't know how to solve this problem without redesigning all the phones and telecommunication systems in the world. Until we do so, contralto's will be sir'd, women with colds will be sir'd, and HBS women will be sir'd from time to time on the phone. The best we can do is take it in stride, correct them when necessary and relevant, and hang-up if the caller can't keep his pronouns straight.
If enough us women start hanging up instead of just taking it, maybe we can change the world.
But then again, we've got to remember, we're dealing with men.
Neither do I.
Wikipedia.
Ms. Lisa Jain Thompson is the Co-Founder & President of TS-Si, Inc. She also serves as a Contributing Editor and columnist for the TS-Si website. Ms. Thompson's signed articles contain her own opinions and do not necessarily convey an official position of TS-Si, its partners, or affiliates.
Lisa welcomes your comments. You can use the public form below or send private correspondence via her TS-Si Contact Page. We will not divulge any personal details or place you on a mailing list without your permission.
Richard Smith, Editor-in-Chief, introduces Cases Journal. Dr. Smith urges all physicians to submit their case reports to the new open access Cases Journal, which publishes case reports from any area of healthcare.
Cases Journal will publish any case report that is understandable, ethical, authentic, and includes all essential information. A more selective companion, the Journal of Medical Case Reports, publishes original and interesting case reports that contribute significantly to medical knowledge. Article submissions are subject to potential publication by either journal. All reports will be entered in a common and open access database.
Ms. Lisa Jain Thompson
Subscribe to this comment's feed
Show/Hide comments
Show/Hide comment form
Copyright © 2005-2008 TS-Si, Inc. Except where noted, this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 2.5 License. Some rights reserved. TS-Si is a nonprofit organization dedicated to the acceptance, medical treatment, & legal protection of individuals in the process of correcting the misalignment of their anatomical sex, & supporting their transition into society.